Image 1 of 1
The Case of the Borrowed Ticket | Forensic Science Mystery Case
The case
At the border stop, half past four in the morning, officers check the papers in compartment seven. The papers describe Stefan Marek, a violin maker of thirty-four: six feet, brown hair, brown eyes. The man in compartment seven is twenty-three, fair, and gray-eyed. The case file lays out three theories for students to test: the passenger's own account, the border officers' deserter theory, and the attendant's borrowed ticket theory. The claim page asks students to weigh what each theory cannot explain.
The driving question: Who is the passenger in compartment seven, and how did he come by another man's papers?
What students do
Groups read the case file, then request evidence cards from the evidence keeper as their questions call for them. Each card is logged before it is used. Students compare a DNA profile at four loci against the profiles in the Suspect Dossier file, read fingerprints lifted from a ticket and a coach seat, compare a signature against a wine list exemplar, and test statements and descriptions against the dossier records. The claim page asks for the claim, the card codes that support it, and the strongest other theory with the reason the evidence does not fit it.
What is included
The download is one ZIP holding six files:
1. Student Case File, 16 pages. How the cases work, the case file, the evidence log, the theory grid and claim page, the print note for the keeper, and 13 evidence cards.
2. Teacher Edition, 12 pages. Facilitator guide, card manifest, correlation guide, solution and reasoning, guidance on the visuals and the physical evidence, Scoring the Claim Pages, and the Dossier Key.
3. Suspect Dossier, 24 pages. All ten suspect profiles and the Examiner's Reference pages, as its own file.
4. Support Slides deck file, 22 slides. The keeper deck for this case, with 13 evidence card slides.
5. Access Sheet, one page. The Google Slides force-copy link printed in full, a QR code beside it, and the contents and printing guidance for the download.
6. Case video, 15 seconds. The pack opening and the Act II sequence from the pack trailer, played to open the lesson.
Google Slides access
Open the Access Sheet and follow the printed link. Google Slides offers a copy of the deck, which saves to your Drive. The Support Slides deck file in the download is the backup copy of the same deck. The slides are images, so the text on a slide cannot be edited.
Printing and setup
Print the Student Case File pages once for each student. Print the evidence card pages once for each group or station. Print the Suspect Dossier file once for each group. Print the Teacher Edition once, for the teacher only. A student evidence keeper holds the cards and the deck slides, and releases each card when a group's questions call for it.
Part of the pack
This single case is one of the three cases in The Orient Express Holiday Cases. The full pack is sold separately. This download carries the complete Suspect Dossier as its own file, so the case runs on its own.
Standards note
Forensic science has no formal NGSS performance expectation set. The Teacher Edition gives the grade band, the standards by practice, and the prerequisites for this case.
The case
At the border stop, half past four in the morning, officers check the papers in compartment seven. The papers describe Stefan Marek, a violin maker of thirty-four: six feet, brown hair, brown eyes. The man in compartment seven is twenty-three, fair, and gray-eyed. The case file lays out three theories for students to test: the passenger's own account, the border officers' deserter theory, and the attendant's borrowed ticket theory. The claim page asks students to weigh what each theory cannot explain.
The driving question: Who is the passenger in compartment seven, and how did he come by another man's papers?
What students do
Groups read the case file, then request evidence cards from the evidence keeper as their questions call for them. Each card is logged before it is used. Students compare a DNA profile at four loci against the profiles in the Suspect Dossier file, read fingerprints lifted from a ticket and a coach seat, compare a signature against a wine list exemplar, and test statements and descriptions against the dossier records. The claim page asks for the claim, the card codes that support it, and the strongest other theory with the reason the evidence does not fit it.
What is included
The download is one ZIP holding six files:
1. Student Case File, 16 pages. How the cases work, the case file, the evidence log, the theory grid and claim page, the print note for the keeper, and 13 evidence cards.
2. Teacher Edition, 12 pages. Facilitator guide, card manifest, correlation guide, solution and reasoning, guidance on the visuals and the physical evidence, Scoring the Claim Pages, and the Dossier Key.
3. Suspect Dossier, 24 pages. All ten suspect profiles and the Examiner's Reference pages, as its own file.
4. Support Slides deck file, 22 slides. The keeper deck for this case, with 13 evidence card slides.
5. Access Sheet, one page. The Google Slides force-copy link printed in full, a QR code beside it, and the contents and printing guidance for the download.
6. Case video, 15 seconds. The pack opening and the Act II sequence from the pack trailer, played to open the lesson.
Google Slides access
Open the Access Sheet and follow the printed link. Google Slides offers a copy of the deck, which saves to your Drive. The Support Slides deck file in the download is the backup copy of the same deck. The slides are images, so the text on a slide cannot be edited.
Printing and setup
Print the Student Case File pages once for each student. Print the evidence card pages once for each group or station. Print the Suspect Dossier file once for each group. Print the Teacher Edition once, for the teacher only. A student evidence keeper holds the cards and the deck slides, and releases each card when a group's questions call for it.
Part of the pack
This single case is one of the three cases in The Orient Express Holiday Cases. The full pack is sold separately. This download carries the complete Suspect Dossier as its own file, so the case runs on its own.
Standards note
Forensic science has no formal NGSS performance expectation set. The Teacher Edition gives the grade band, the standards by practice, and the prerequisites for this case.