Image 1 of 1
The Mustachioed Master | Forensic Science Mystery Case
The case
On the gala's portrait wall hangs its loan centerpiece, "The Amber Duchess," a seventeenth-century oil portrait under glass. By morning the cover glass carries a handlebar mustache, etched across the sitter's upper lip. The painting beneath is untouched. The glass is ruined.
The driving question: Who etched the mustache on "The Amber Duchess," and what actually happened to the glass?
What students do
Groups read the case file and the interviews, then request evidence cards from the evidence keeper as their questions call for them. Each card is logged before it is used. Students compare tool marks scored in glass and glass samples measured against the portrait's cover glass, read fibers on a ledge and a line of wheelchair tracks, compare the handwriting of a note left beside the frame against the dossier samples, and work through the night logs and a bench tool inventory. The claim page asks for the claim, the evidence that supports it, the reasoning that joins the lines, and the strongest counterclaim.
What is included
The download is one ZIP holding the case's files:
1. Student Case File, 27 pages. How the cases work, the suspect file and the reference pages, the case file, the suspects, the interviews, 14 evidence cards, the evidence log, and the claim page.
2. Teacher Edition, 9 pages. Running the cases, grade band, standards, and prerequisites, the If They Ask facilitator guide for this case, the solution, the interview claim key, and Scoring the Claim Pages. The formatted teacher-side evidence key for the Museum pack, profiles 032 to 040, ships beside it as its own teacher-only file, 14 pages.
3. Suspect Dossier, 41 pages. All nine Museum Gala suspect profiles, as its own file.
4. Support Slides deck file: the keeper deck for this case, with the evidence cards as slides.
5. Access Sheet, one page. The Google Slides force-copy link printed in full, a QR code beside it, and the contents and printing guidance for the download.
6. Case video: the case introduction, played to open the lesson.
Google Slides access
Open the Access Sheet and follow the printed link. Google Slides offers a copy of the deck, which saves to your Drive. The Support Slides deck file in the download is the backup copy of the same deck. The slides are images, so the text on a slide cannot be edited.
Printing and setup
Print the case pages of the Student Case File once for each student, without the evidence card pages. Print the evidence card pages once for the keeper and cut each page on the dashed line. Print the Suspect Dossier file once for each group. Print the Teacher Edition and the teacher-side evidence key once, for the teacher only. A student evidence keeper holds the cards and releases each card when a group's questions call for it. The case runs in one to two class periods.
Part of the pack
This single case is one of the three cases in The Museum Gala Mystery Cases. The full pack is sold separately as the Museum Gala Super Pack. This download carries the complete Suspect Dossier as its own file, so the case runs on its own.
This case is the full version: 14 evidence cards, the full interviews, and the complete nine-profile Suspect Dossier.
Standards note
Forensic science has no formal NGSS performance expectation set. The Teacher Edition gives the grade band, the alignment by practice, and the prerequisites for this case. The alignment names nonlinear inquiry-based learning: students build the account of the night from evidence they request, log, and weigh, and the second paragraph of a case's work is the claim they defend at the reveal.
The case
On the gala's portrait wall hangs its loan centerpiece, "The Amber Duchess," a seventeenth-century oil portrait under glass. By morning the cover glass carries a handlebar mustache, etched across the sitter's upper lip. The painting beneath is untouched. The glass is ruined.
The driving question: Who etched the mustache on "The Amber Duchess," and what actually happened to the glass?
What students do
Groups read the case file and the interviews, then request evidence cards from the evidence keeper as their questions call for them. Each card is logged before it is used. Students compare tool marks scored in glass and glass samples measured against the portrait's cover glass, read fibers on a ledge and a line of wheelchair tracks, compare the handwriting of a note left beside the frame against the dossier samples, and work through the night logs and a bench tool inventory. The claim page asks for the claim, the evidence that supports it, the reasoning that joins the lines, and the strongest counterclaim.
What is included
The download is one ZIP holding the case's files:
1. Student Case File, 27 pages. How the cases work, the suspect file and the reference pages, the case file, the suspects, the interviews, 14 evidence cards, the evidence log, and the claim page.
2. Teacher Edition, 9 pages. Running the cases, grade band, standards, and prerequisites, the If They Ask facilitator guide for this case, the solution, the interview claim key, and Scoring the Claim Pages. The formatted teacher-side evidence key for the Museum pack, profiles 032 to 040, ships beside it as its own teacher-only file, 14 pages.
3. Suspect Dossier, 41 pages. All nine Museum Gala suspect profiles, as its own file.
4. Support Slides deck file: the keeper deck for this case, with the evidence cards as slides.
5. Access Sheet, one page. The Google Slides force-copy link printed in full, a QR code beside it, and the contents and printing guidance for the download.
6. Case video: the case introduction, played to open the lesson.
Google Slides access
Open the Access Sheet and follow the printed link. Google Slides offers a copy of the deck, which saves to your Drive. The Support Slides deck file in the download is the backup copy of the same deck. The slides are images, so the text on a slide cannot be edited.
Printing and setup
Print the case pages of the Student Case File once for each student, without the evidence card pages. Print the evidence card pages once for the keeper and cut each page on the dashed line. Print the Suspect Dossier file once for each group. Print the Teacher Edition and the teacher-side evidence key once, for the teacher only. A student evidence keeper holds the cards and releases each card when a group's questions call for it. The case runs in one to two class periods.
Part of the pack
This single case is one of the three cases in The Museum Gala Mystery Cases. The full pack is sold separately as the Museum Gala Super Pack. This download carries the complete Suspect Dossier as its own file, so the case runs on its own.
This case is the full version: 14 evidence cards, the full interviews, and the complete nine-profile Suspect Dossier.
Standards note
Forensic science has no formal NGSS performance expectation set. The Teacher Edition gives the grade band, the alignment by practice, and the prerequisites for this case. The alignment names nonlinear inquiry-based learning: students build the account of the night from evidence they request, log, and weigh, and the second paragraph of a case's work is the claim they defend at the reveal.